Sandwich Shops and Delis in Buffalo, NY

Sandwiches and delis in Buffalo at a glance

• Sandwiches and delis is the 5th largest food category in Buffalo, after bars and coffee shops and cafes.
• Its 4.6% share compares with 4.9% across the 506 cities in this guide, close to the national pattern.
• Of the 58 listed below, 43 are independent and 15 belong to chains; 49 list a website.

Sandwich Shops and Delis in Buffalo

• Joe's Deli
  Restaurant · Sandwiches and delis · 818 Ellicott St
• Fera's Lunch Hour
  Restaurant · Sandwiches and delis · 93 Pearl St
• Buffalo's Golden Corner
  Restaurant · Sandwiches and delis · 1715 Jefferson Ave
• Charlie The Butcher's Carvery
  Restaurant · Sandwiches and delis · Chain · 770 Elmwood Ave
• Chris' NY Sandwich Co
  Restaurant · Sandwiches and delis · 395 Delaware Ave
• High Street Deli
  Restaurant · Sandwiches and delis · 195 High St Deli
• Jim's Steakout
  Restaurant · Sandwiches and delis · Chain · 194 Allen St
• Joe's Deli
  Restaurant · Sandwiches and delis · 1322 Hertel Ave
• Moura's New York Style Deli
  Restaurant · Sandwiches and delis · 9 Court St
• Steffie's Food Mart
  Restaurant · Sandwiches and delis · 1592 Elmwood Ave
• The Lunch Box
  Restaurant · Sandwiches and delis · 465 Main St
• Zio's Deli & Heroes
  Restaurant · Sandwiches and delis · 1055 Elmwood Ave
• Subway
  Restaurant · Sandwiches and delis · Chain · 2168 Delaware Ave
• Holley Farms Deli
  Restaurant · Sandwiches and delis · 233 Allen St #1417
• Subway
  Restaurant · Sandwiches and delis · Chain · 120 W Chippewa St
• Progress Food Market
  Restaurant · Sandwiches and delis · 289 Hamburg St
• Subway
  Restaurant · Sandwiches and delis · Chain · 462 Grider St
• Panera Bread
  Restaurant · Sandwiches and delis · Chain · 765 Elmwood Ave
• Subway
  Restaurant · Sandwiches and delis · Chain · 3382 Main St
• Subway
  Restaurant · Sandwiches and delis · Chain · 363 Hopkins St
• Sue's NY Deli
  Restaurant · Sandwiches and delis · 598 Main St
• Doyle's Deli
  Restaurant · Sandwiches and delis · 1981 Niagara St, 1981 Niagara St
• Rainbow Deli
  Restaurant · Sandwiches and delis · Chain · 403 Main St #110
• Subway
  Restaurant · Sandwiches and delis · Chain · 410 Main St
• Subway
  Restaurant · Sandwiches and delis · Chain · 2730 Delaware Ave
• Roly Poly
  Restaurant · Sandwiches and delis · 846 Main St
• Charlie the Butcher's Express
  Restaurant · Sandwiches and delis · Chain · Grand Lobby, Ellicott Square Building, 295 Main St
• Buffalo Melting Point
  Restaurant · Sandwiches and delis · 244 Allen St
• Mister Submarine
  Restaurant · Sandwiches and delis · 1977 South Park Ave
• Griddle & Greens
  Restaurant · Sandwiches and delis · 295 Main St
• Cedars Bakery and Deli
  Restaurant · Sandwiches and delis · 111 Dingens St
• D'Avolio Kitchen
  Restaurant · Sandwiches and delis · 535 Main St
• Dagwood's and More
  Restaurant · Sandwiches and delis · 1832 Main St
• Erbert & Gerbert's
  Restaurant · Sandwiches and delis · 484 Elmwood Ave
• Globe Market
  Restaurant · Sandwiches and delis · 298 Main St
• Jimmy John's
  Restaurant · Sandwiches and delis · Chain · 770 Elmwood Ave
• Pete-n-Paul's Pockets
  Restaurant · Sandwiches and delis · 2124 S Park Ave
• Quaker Bonnet Eatery
  Restaurant · Sandwiches and delis · 175 Allen St
• Salumeria Belsito
  Restaurant · Sandwiches and delis · 1368 Hertel Ave
• Shy's Downtown Steak Shop
  Restaurant · Sandwiches and delis · 397 Jefferson Ave
• Subway
  Restaurant · Sandwiches and delis · Chain · 3167 Bailey Ave
• The Lunch Box
  Restaurant · Sandwiches and delis · 300 Pearl St
• Brawler's Back Alley Deli
  Restaurant · Sandwiches and delis · 76 1/2 Pearl St
• Fillmore Food Market
  Restaurant · Sandwiches and delis · 2189 Fillmore Ave
• Marco's Italian Deli
  Restaurant · Sandwiches and delis · 1744 Hertel Ave
• Marina Market Deli
  Restaurant · Sandwiches and delis · 31 Marine Dr
• Nadeem's Grocery & Deli
  Restaurant · Sandwiches and delis · 2082 S Park Ave
• Potts Deli and Grille
  Restaurant · Sandwiches and delis · 694 S Ogden St # 2317
• Sue's New York Deli
  Restaurant · Sandwiches and delis · 130 S Elmwood Ave
• Buffalo Meats & Deli
  Restaurant · Sandwiches and delis · 1036 E Ferry St
• Sherman Deli
  Restaurant · Sandwiches and delis · 819 Genesee St
• united deli
  Restaurant · Sandwiches and delis · Chain · 161 Deerfield Ave
• Good Guys Deli and Grill
  Restaurant · Sandwiches and delis · 315 Jersey St
• The Hoagie Stop
  Restaurant · Sandwiches and delis · 2285 Main St
• Potts Deli & Grille at the Broadway Market
  Restaurant · Sandwiches and delis · 999 Broadway
• E Ferry Food and Deli
  Restaurant · Sandwiches and delis · 1326 E Ferry St
• Texas City Market & Deli
  Restaurant · Sandwiches and delis · 1245 E Delavan Ave
• Malia's Steak Shop
  Restaurant · Sandwiches and delis · 647 Northumberland Ave

Sandwiches and delis elsewhere in New York

Among the New York cities in this guide, the most sandwiches and delis listings are in New York (2641), Yonkers (73), Rochester (51), Syracuse (40), Albany (38) and New Rochelle (28).

Run a sandwiches and delis spot in Buffalo?

You share this list with 57 other sandwiches and delis listings. The ones guests reorder from are the ones that are easy to order from directly. Servestack gives you your own ordering site with zero commission, and Studio designs the menu, flyers and posts to go with it. Run your numbers with the commission savings calculator.

Place data from the Overture Maps Foundation (overturemaps.org), which includes data from Meta, Microsoft and Foursquare, used under the CDLA Permissive 2.0 and Apache 2.0 licenses. Restaurants open, close and move; check with the restaurant before you go. Data refreshed 2026-10-11.