Pizza Places in Buffalo, NY

Pizza in Buffalo at a glance

• Pizza is the 3rd largest food category in Buffalo, after bars and coffee shops and cafes.
• Its 6.6% share compares with 6.3% across the 506 cities in this guide, close to the national pattern.
• Of the 60 listed below, 50 are independent and 10 belong to chains; 60 list a website.

Pizza Places in Buffalo

Showing 60 of 83, listings with a website first.

• JJs Casa Di Pizza
  Restaurant · Pizza · Chain · 11 E Mohawk St
• Brick Oven Bistro
  Restaurant · Pizza · 904 Abbott Rd
• Gino & Joes NY Pizza ( DOWNTOWN )
  Restaurant · Pizza · 403 Main St
• Pizza By Molino's
  Restaurant · Pizza · 1974 Clinton St
• Guzzo's Hot Spot
  Restaurant · Pizza · 1960 Clinton St
• Gino and Joes South Buffalo
  Restaurant · Pizza · 141 Abbott Rd
• Emergency Pizza
  Restaurant · Pizza · 1870 Seneca St
• Imperial Pizza
  Restaurant · Pizza · 1035 Abbott Rd
• Artone's Pizza and Subs
  Restaurant · Pizza · 1882 Seneca St
• Bailey Avenue Pizza
  Restaurant · Pizza · 2916 Bailey Ave
• Bob & John's La Hacienda
  Restaurant · Pizza · 1545 Hertel Ave
• Buffalo Bites Pizzeria
  Restaurant · Pizza · Chain · 2368 Seneca St
• Carbone's Pizza
  Restaurant · Pizza · 1126 E Lovejoy St
• Carbone's Pizza & Subs
  Restaurant · Pizza · 568 South Park Ave
• Chuck's
  Restaurant · Pizza · 35 North St
• Domino's
  Restaurant · Pizza · Chain · 1105 Broadway St
• Extra Extra Pizza
  Restaurant · Pizza · 549 W Utica St
• Gino's NY Pizza Elmwood
  Restaurant · Pizza · 1009 Elmwood Ave
• Joe's New York Style Pizza
  Restaurant · Pizza · 345 Amherst St
• Just Pizza
  Restaurant · Pizza · 2350 Delaware Ave
• Just Pizza & Wing
  Restaurant · Pizza · 300 Elmwood Ave
• La Nova Pizzeria
  Restaurant · Pizza · Chain · 371 W Ferry St
• La Pizza Club
  Restaurant · Pizza · 1511 Hertel Ave
• Little Caesars Pizza
  Restaurant · Pizza · Chain · 2290 Delaware Ave STE 200
• Lovejoy Pizza
  Restaurant · Pizza · 900 Main St
• Lovejoy Pizzeria
  Restaurant · Pizza · 1244 E Lovejoy St
• Metro Pizza Co
  Restaurant · Pizza · 920 Clinton St
• Mineo's South Pizzeria
  Restaurant · Pizza · 2154 South Park Ave
• Mister Pizza Elmwood
  Restaurant · Pizza · Chain · 1065 Elmwood Ave
• Niagara Deli & Pizzeria
  Restaurant · Pizza · 2043 Niagara St
• Pat's Pizzeria
  Restaurant · Pizza · 544 Ontario St
• Pizza Hut
  Restaurant · Pizza · Chain · 2150 Delaware Ave Erie
• Pizza Town
  Restaurant · Pizza · 859 Niagara St
• Ricottas Pizza Niagara
  Restaurant · Pizza · 349 Niagara St
• South Park Pizza and Deli
  Restaurant · Pizza · 1727 South Park Ave
• Tuscan Pizza Crust
  Restaurant · Pizza · 2021 Bailey Ave
• Wise Guys Pizza Buffalo
  Restaurant · Pizza · 1965 Seneca St
• Abbott Rd Pizza
  Restaurant · Pizza · 1177 Abbott Rd
• Ferry Express 5
  Restaurant · Pizza · 1507 Fillmore Ave
• Kensington Pizza
  Restaurant · Pizza · 1463 Kensington Ave
• Buffalo Deep Dish
  Restaurant · Pizza
• Ricota's Pizza
  Restaurant · Pizza · 206 Elk St #2
• Jacobi's Restaurant & Pizzeria
  Restaurant · Pizza · 141 Abbott Rd 141
• Ld's Pizzeria
  Restaurant · Pizza · 2249 S Park Ave 2249
• Blasdell Pizza
  Restaurant · Pizza · 2370 Seneca St
• Desi's Pizzeria
  Restaurant · Pizza · 1816 Clinton St
• Just Pizza- South Park Avenue
  Restaurant · Pizza · 2249 S Park Ave
• Avenue Pizza on Hertel
  Restaurant · Pizza · 1116 Hertel Ave
• Jo Jo's Pizza and Subs
  Restaurant · Pizza · 528 Abbott Rd
• Just Pizza
  Restaurant · Pizza · 3172 Main St
• Pizza Express
  Restaurant · Pizza · Chain · 1993 Broadway
• Jet's Pizza
  Restaurant · Pizza · Chain · 2165 Delaware Ave
• Sam's Pizza
  Restaurant · Pizza · 1393 Kensington Ave
• Allentown Pizza
  Restaurant · Pizza · 94 Elmwood Ave
• Papa Johns Pizza
  Restaurant · Pizza · Chain · 1155 Main St
• Leo's Pizzeria
  Restaurant · Pizza · 2077 Seneca St
• Bocce Club Pizza
  Restaurant · Pizza · 235 Delaware Ave
• Bocce Club Pizza on Hertel
  Restaurant · Pizza · 1488 Hertel Ave
• 241 Pizza
  Restaurant · Pizza · 1122 Elmwood Ave
• Bflo Pizza Bistro
  Restaurant · Pizza · 388 Porter Ave

Pizza elsewhere in New York

Among the New York cities in this guide, the most pizza listings are in New York (2662), Rochester (71), Yonkers (53), Syracuse (52), Albany (41) and New Rochelle (23).

Run a pizza spot in Buffalo?

You share this list with 82 other pizza listings. The ones guests reorder from are the ones that are easy to order from directly. Servestack gives you your own ordering site with zero commission, and Studio designs the menu, flyers and posts to go with it. Run your numbers with the commission savings calculator.

Place data from the Overture Maps Foundation (overturemaps.org), which includes data from Meta, Microsoft and Foursquare, used under the CDLA Permissive 2.0 and Apache 2.0 licenses. Restaurants open, close and move; check with the restaurant before you go. Data refreshed 2026-10-11.