Dessert and Ice Cream Shops in Buffalo, NY

Desserts and ice cream in Buffalo at a glance

• Desserts and ice cream is the 8th largest food category in Buffalo, after bars and coffee shops and cafes.
• Its 3.1% share compares with 3.8% across the 506 cities in this guide, close to the national pattern.
• Of the 39 listed below, 32 are independent and 7 belong to chains; 34 list a website.

Dessert and Ice Cream Shops in Buffalo

• Anderson's Frozen Custard
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · Chain · 2634 Delaware Ave
• Cookies & Cream
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · Chain · 929 Elmwood Ave
• Golden Hour Treats & Things
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · 735 Sycamore St
• Hanna's Frosty Treats
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · 140 Taunton Pl
• Pam's Custard Corner
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · 2190 South Park Ave
• Parkside Candy
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · Chain · 3208 Main St
• Tomric
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · 85 River Rock Dr
• Lake Effect Ice Cream
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · 1900 Hertel Ave
• Billionaire Creamery
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · 451 Elmwood Ave
• Jerk's Soda Fountain & Ice Cream
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · 523 Main St
• Custard Corner & Grill
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · 211 Porter Ave
• Abbott Ice Cream -n- Stuff
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · 368 Abbott Rd
• Fowler's Chocolates
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · 100 River Rock Dr Ste 102
• Park Edge Sweet Shoppe
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · 325 Abbott Rd
• Cookies & Cream
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · Chain · 2114 Seneca St
• Aladdin Grill House
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · 754 Sycamore St
• B Sweet Designs
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · 799 Seneca St
• Bryce's Ice Cream
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · 1 Naval Park Cv
• Butterwood Desserts
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · 391 Washington St
• Chocolate Shop
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · 871 Niagara St
• Cold Stone Creamery
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · Chain · 537 Delaware Ave
• Cold Stone Creamery
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · Chain · 2674 Delaware Ave
• Ko-Ed Candies
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · 285 Abbott Rd
• Landies Candies
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · 2495 Main St Ste 350
• Major Cool Off
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · 361 Dingens St
• Mighty Taco
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · 462 Grider St
• Perry's Ice Cream
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · 329 Erie St
• Sweet Tooth
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · 94 Elmwood Ave
• The Yard Ice Cream
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · 33 Spann St
• Thinking Elvish Fantasy Chocolate
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · 423 Elmwood Ave
• White Rabbit Frozen Yogurt
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · 802 Elmwood Ave
• White Rabbit Frozen Yogurt
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · 2290 Delaware Ave
• Sweet Melody's
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · 999 Broadway
• We R Nuts
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · 999 Broadway
• Sweet Mix Buffalo
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · 1096 E Lovejoy St
• Carriage Trade Pastries
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · 1654 Elmwood Ave
• Sweet Variations
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · 838 Niagara St
• Cookies & Cream on the Water
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · Chain · 1111 Fuhrmann Blvd
• Platters Chocolates
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · 285 Abbott Rd

Desserts and ice cream elsewhere in New York

Among the New York cities in this guide, the most desserts and ice cream listings are in New York (1381), Yonkers (23), Syracuse (18), New Rochelle (17), Rochester (14) and Albany (11).

Run a desserts and ice cream spot in Buffalo?

You share this list with 38 other desserts and ice cream listings. The ones guests reorder from are the ones that are easy to order from directly. Servestack gives you your own ordering site with zero commission, and Studio designs the menu, flyers and posts to go with it. Run your numbers with the commission savings calculator.

Place data from the Overture Maps Foundation (overturemaps.org), which includes data from Meta, Microsoft and Foursquare, used under the CDLA Permissive 2.0 and Apache 2.0 licenses. Restaurants open, close and move; check with the restaurant before you go. Data refreshed 2026-10-11.