Sandwich Shops and Delis in Carmel, IN

Sandwiches and delis in Carmel at a glance

• Sandwiches and delis is the 3rd largest food category in Carmel, after coffee shops and cafes and pizza.
• Its 6.9% share compares with 4.9% across the 506 cities in this guide, so Carmel leans toward sandwiches and delis.
• Of the 29 listed below, 8 are independent and 21 belong to chains; 26 list a website.

Sandwich Shops and Delis in Carmel

• Fat Dan's Chicago-Style Deli
  Restaurant · Sandwiches and delis · Chain · 840 W Main St
• McAlister's Deli
  Restaurant · Sandwiches and delis · Chain · 2355 E 116th St
• Jersey Mike's
  Restaurant · Sandwiches and delis · Chain · 2271 Pointe Parkway
• Jimmy John's
  Restaurant · Sandwiches and delis · Chain · 9893 N Michigan Rd Ste. 130
• Jimmy John's
  Restaurant · Sandwiches and delis · Chain · 2810 E 116th St Ste 140 Ste. 140
• Penn Station East Coast Subs
  Restaurant · Sandwiches and delis · Chain · 841 S Rangeline Rd
• Potbelly
  Restaurant · Sandwiches and delis · Chain · 11529 Spring Mill Rd #100
• Which Wich
  Restaurant · Sandwiches and delis · Chain · 4335 W 106th St Unit 1200
• Which Wich Carmel Shops
  Restaurant · Sandwiches and delis · 1430 W Carmel Dr Ste 140
• Subway
  Restaurant · Sandwiches and delis · Chain · 528 E Carmel Dr
• Jimmy John's
  Restaurant · Sandwiches and delis · Chain · 14250 Clay Terrace Blvd
• Subway
  Restaurant · Sandwiches and delis · Chain · 4000 W. 106th St Suite 130
• Jersey Mike's
  Restaurant · Sandwiches and delis · Chain · 10725 N. Michigan Rd. Suite A
• Jimmy John's
  Restaurant · Sandwiches and delis · Chain · 365 W 116th St Ste. 100
• Subway
  Restaurant · Sandwiches and delis · Chain · 13190 Hazel Dell Parkway
• Subway
  Restaurant · Sandwiches and delis · Chain · 11711 N Pennsylvania St Suite 115
• Carmel Sand & Gravel
  Restaurant · Sandwiches and delis · 10851 Hazel Dell Pkwy
• Joe's Next Door
  Restaurant · Sandwiches and delis · 111 W Main St
• Capriotti's Sandwich Shop
  Restaurant · Sandwiches and delis · Chain · 11100 N Michigan Rd Ste 120
• Lenny's Sub Shop
  Restaurant · Sandwiches and delis · Chain · 820 E 116th St
• Roly Poly Sandwiches
  Restaurant · Sandwiches and delis · Chain · 12261 N Meridian St
• SUBWAY
  Restaurant · Sandwiches and delis · Chain · 12261 N Meridian St
• W.G. Grinders
  Restaurant · Sandwiches and delis · 12297 N Meridian St
• Earl of Sandwich
  Restaurant · Sandwiches and delis · 1 E Carmel Dr Ste 170
• Jason's Deli
  Restaurant · Sandwiches and delis · Chain · 12405 N Meridian St
• Palm Deli
  Restaurant · Sandwiches and delis · 10400 N Michigan Rd # 3
• Meridian Plaza Deli
  Restaurant · Sandwiches and delis · 10333 N Meridian St Ste 190
• Great Harvest Bread Co - Carmel, IN
  Restaurant · Sandwiches and delis · 12505 Old Meridian St Ste 100
• Carmel – Spring Mill Rd.
  Restaurant · Sandwiches and delis · Chain · 11529 Springmill Road

Sandwiches and delis elsewhere in Indiana

Among the Indiana cities in this guide, the most sandwiches and delis listings are in Indianapolis (177), Fort Wayne (62), Evansville (40), Bloomington (28), South Bend (26) and Fishers (18).

Run a sandwiches and delis spot in Carmel?

You share this list with 28 other sandwiches and delis listings. The ones guests reorder from are the ones that are easy to order from directly. Servestack gives you your own ordering site with zero commission, and Studio designs the menu, flyers and posts to go with it. Run your numbers with the commission savings calculator.

Place data from the Overture Maps Foundation (overturemaps.org), which includes data from Meta, Microsoft and Foursquare, used under the CDLA Permissive 2.0 and Apache 2.0 licenses. Restaurants open, close and move; check with the restaurant before you go. Data refreshed 2026-10-11.