Pizza Places in Carmel, IN

Pizza in Carmel at a glance

• Pizza is the 2nd largest food category in Carmel, after coffee shops and cafes.
• Its 9.1% share compares with 6.3% across the 506 cities in this guide, so Carmel leans toward pizza.
• Of the 38 listed below, 15 are independent and 23 belong to chains; 35 list a website.

Pizza Places in Carmel

• Pies and Pints
  Restaurant · Pizza · Chain · 14550 Clay Terrace Blvd
• Blaze Pizza
  Restaurant · Pizza · Chain · 12697 N Pennsylvania St Unit 140
• Greek's Pizzeria
  Restaurant · Pizza · Chain · 120 E Main St
• Bazbeaux Pizza
  Restaurant · Pizza · Chain · 111 W Main St
• Donatos Pizza
  Restaurant · Pizza · Chain · 1311 South Rangeline Road
• Greek Tony's Pizza & Sub Shop
  Restaurant · Pizza · 1732 E 116th St
• HotBox Pizza
  Restaurant · Pizza · Chain · 1 E Carmel Dr #170
• King Dough Carmel
  Restaurant · Pizza · Chain · 12505 Old Meridian St Apt 170
• Noble Roman's Craft Pizza and Pub
  Restaurant · Pizza · Chain · 1438 W Main St
• Roselli's Pizza
  Restaurant · Pizza · 4335 W 106th St
• Puccini's Pizza Pasta-Carme
  Restaurant · Pizza · Chain · 13674 N Meridian St
• Sauce on the Side
  Restaurant · Pizza · Chain · 12751 N Pennsylvania St Ste 130
• HotBox Pizza
  Restaurant · Pizza · Chain · 4400 Weston Pointe Dr #160
• Pizza King Carmel
  Restaurant · Pizza · 301 E Carmel Dr
• Greek's Pizzeria
  Restaurant · Pizza · Chain · 12703 Meeting House Rd
• Mellow Mushroom
  Restaurant · Pizza · Chain · 2340 E 116th St
• Domino's
  Restaurant · Pizza · Chain · 1441 S. Guilford Rd. Suite 110
• Papa John's Pizza
  Restaurant · Pizza · Chain · 10598 N College Ave
• Hunt Brothers Pizza
  Restaurant · Pizza · Chain · 9802 N Michigan Rd
• Bella Pizzeria
  Restaurant · Pizza · Chain · 14550 Clay Terrace Blvd
• Bellacino's
  Restaurant · Pizza · 12590 N Meridian St
• Greeks Pizzeria 96th and College
  Restaurant · Pizza · Chain · 9613 N College Ave
• Luca Pizza
  Restaurant · Pizza · 890 E 116th St Ste 100
• Marco's Pizza
  Restaurant · Pizza · Chain · 11145 N Michigan Rd Ste 110
• Noble Roman's
  Restaurant · Pizza · 9873 N Michigan Rd
• Noble Roman's
  Restaurant · Pizza · 1422 Keystone Way
• Noble Romans Pizza & Breadsticks
  Restaurant · Pizza · 617 3rd Ave SW
• Pizza 317
  Restaurant · Pizza · 14580 River Rd Ste 190
• Pizza King
  Restaurant · Pizza · 902 S Rangeline Rd
• Pizzology Craft Pizza + Pub
  Restaurant · Pizza · 12819 E New Market St
• Some Guys Pizza
  Restaurant · Pizza · 12552 N Gray Rd
• Tony Sacco's Coal Oven Pizza
  Restaurant · Pizza · 14405 Clay Terrace Blvd
• Carmel, IN - Pennsylvania St
  Restaurant · Pizza · Chain · 12697 N. Pennsylvania St, Suite 140
• Noble Roman's
  Restaurant · Pizza · 1224 S Guilford Rd
• Donatos Pizza
  Restaurant · Pizza · Chain · 4100 West 106th Street
• Noble Roman's
  Restaurant · Pizza · 3905 W 96th St
• Rosati's Pizza
  Restaurant · Pizza · Chain · 890 E 116th St
• Pizza Hut
  Restaurant · Pizza · Chain · 705 S Rangeline Rd

Pizza elsewhere in Indiana

Among the Indiana cities in this guide, the most pizza listings are in Indianapolis (311), Fort Wayne (101), Evansville (90), Fishers (45), Bloomington (43) and South Bend (36).

Run a pizza spot in Carmel?

You share this list with 37 other pizza listings. The ones guests reorder from are the ones that are easy to order from directly. Servestack gives you your own ordering site with zero commission, and Studio designs the menu, flyers and posts to go with it. Run your numbers with the commission savings calculator.

Place data from the Overture Maps Foundation (overturemaps.org), which includes data from Meta, Microsoft and Foursquare, used under the CDLA Permissive 2.0 and Apache 2.0 licenses. Restaurants open, close and move; check with the restaurant before you go. Data refreshed 2026-10-11.