Dessert and Ice Cream Shops in Tallahassee, FL

Desserts and ice cream in Tallahassee at a glance

• Desserts and ice cream is the 8th largest food category in Tallahassee, after bars and coffee shops and cafes.
• Its 3.1% share compares with 3.8% across the 506 cities in this guide, close to the national pattern.
• Of the 36 listed below, 22 are independent and 14 belong to chains; 33 list a website.

Dessert and Ice Cream Shops in Tallahassee

• Barb's Southern Style Gourmet
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · 1671 N Monroe St
• Cold Stone Creamery
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · Chain · 1444 W Tennessee St
• Bruster's Real Ice Cream
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · Chain · 1709 W Tharpe St
• Cold Stone Creamery
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · Chain · 2415 N Monroe St, Ste 1108
• Crumbl - Fsu
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · 1670 W Tennessee St Ste 1
• Crumbl - Mahan Village
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · 3122 Mahan Dr Ste 302
• Nuberri
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · 101 N Blair Stone Rd
• Ryder’s Water Ice
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · 608 Railroad Sq Unit 1
• SouthWood Sweets
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · 3197 Merchants Row Blvd Ste. 130
• Bruster's Real Ice Cream
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · Chain · 2475 Apalachee Pkwy
• 32 Degree Creamery
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · Ocala Corner Shopping Center, 800 Ocala Rd Suite #340
• Sneauxball Catering Co.
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · 2033 S Adams St
• Jeremiah's Italian Ice
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · Chain · 1400 Village Square Blvd Ste 32
• Artistic Confections
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · 1712 Thomasville Rd
• Baskin Robbins
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · 904 Thomasville Rd
• BIG RIG Desserts
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · 535 Silver Slipper Ln
• Diva Pops Creamery
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · 2121 W Pensacola St Ste B1
• Fiocco Gelato Café
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · 2415 N Monroe St Ste 300
• Haagen Dazs
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · 4447 Entrepot Blvd
• Hagen-Dazs
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · Chain · 1500 Apalachee Pkwy
• Jeremiah's Italian Ice
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · Chain · 619 S Woodward Ave
• Marble Slab Creamery
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · Chain · 1400 Village Square Blvd
• More Than Pudding
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · 3020 W Pensacola St
• Nuberri
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · 2910 Kerry Forest Pkwy Ste D6
• Public Displays of Confection
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · 1355 Market St
• Sunberry
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · 633 W Tennessee St
• TCBY
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · Chain · 2530 N Monroe St
• Cold Stone Creamery
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · Chain · 1444 W Tennessee St, # 2
• Mahan Village
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · Chain · 3122 Mahan Dr, Ste 302, Tallahassee, Florida 32308
• Rita's Italian Ice
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · Chain · 2020 West Pensacola Street
• Sugar Rush
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · 414 All Saints St
• Sneauxball Drive Thru
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · 2049 N Monroe St
• Peter Brooke Chocolatier
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · Chain · 3491 Thomasville Rd
• Love Gurlies
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · Walmart Plaza, 4212 W Tennessee St
• Baskin-Robbins
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · Chain · 3440 Thomasville Rd
• Candy Cove Sweets
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · 1500 Apalachee Pkwy Ste 2195

Desserts and ice cream elsewhere in Florida

Among the Florida cities in this guide, the most desserts and ice cream listings are in Jacksonville (129), Orlando (126), Miami (121), Tampa (99), Miami Beach (63) and St. Petersburg (50).

Run a desserts and ice cream spot in Tallahassee?

You share this list with 35 other desserts and ice cream listings. The ones guests reorder from are the ones that are easy to order from directly. Servestack gives you your own ordering site with zero commission, and Studio designs the menu, flyers and posts to go with it. Run your numbers with the commission savings calculator.

Place data from the Overture Maps Foundation (overturemaps.org), which includes data from Meta, Microsoft and Foursquare, used under the CDLA Permissive 2.0 and Apache 2.0 licenses. Restaurants open, close and move; check with the restaurant before you go. Data refreshed 2026-10-11.