Italian Restaurants in Indianapolis, IN

Italian in Indianapolis at a glance

• Italian is the 19th largest food category in Indianapolis, after bars and pizza.
• Its 1.2% share compares with 2.1% across the 506 cities in this guide, so it is thinner here than in most cities.
• Of the 44 listed below, 31 are independent and 13 belong to chains; 43 list a website.

Italian Restaurants in Indianapolis

• Abbiocco Pizzeria
  Restaurant · Italian · 906 Carrollton Ave
• Fresco Italian Cafe
  Restaurant · Italian · 310 W Michigan St
• Maialina
  Restaurant · Italian · 1103 Prospect St
• Diavola Pizza
  Restaurant · Italian · 1134 E 54th St
• Rosemary & Olive Italian Restaurant
  Restaurant · Italian · 870 Massachusetts Ave
• Pasquale's Pizza and Pasta
  Restaurant · Italian · 7755 E Washington St
• Iaria's Italian Restaurant
  Restaurant · Italian · 317 S College Ave
• Iozzo's Garden of Italy
  Restaurant · Italian · 946 S Meridian St
• Maggiano's Little Italy
  Restaurant · Italian · Chain · 3550 E. 86th St.
• Ambrosia
  Restaurant · Italian · 5903 N College Ave
• Bocca
  Restaurant · Italian · 122 E 22nd St
• Capri Italian Restaurant
  Restaurant · Italian · 2602 Ruth Dr
• Carrabba's Italian Grill
  Restaurant · Italian · Chain · 4690 Southport Crossing Dr
• Fazoli's
  Restaurant · Italian · Chain · 5202 W Washington St
• Flights Craft Bar and Kitchen
  Restaurant · Italian · 2544 Executive Dr
• Piada Italian Street Food
  Restaurant · Italian · Chain · 8601 River Crossing Blvd
• Puccini's Pizza Pasta
  Restaurant · Italian · Chain · 1508 W 86th St
• The Old Spaghetti Factory
  Restaurant · Italian · Chain · 210 S Meridian St
• Vito Provolone's
  Restaurant · Italian · 8031 S Meridian St
• Buca di Beppo Italian Restaurant
  Restaurant · Italian · Chain · 35 N Illinois St
• Vicino
  Restaurant · Italian · 350 Massachusetts Ave Ste 150
• Nesso Italian Kitchen
  Restaurant · Italian · 339 S Delaware St
• Balena Cucina Italiana
  Restaurant · Italian · 1454 W 86th St
• Some Guys Pizza Pasta Grill
  Restaurant · Italian · 6235 Allisonville Rd
• Sangiovese Ristorante
  Restaurant · Italian · 2727 E 86th St
• Olive Garden
  Restaurant · Italian · Chain · 6130 E 82nd St
• Mama Carolla's
  Restaurant · Italian · 1031 E 54th St
• Olive Garden Italian Restaurant
  Restaurant · Italian · Chain · 8155 E Washington St
• Puccini's Pizza Pasta - Clearwater
  Restaurant · Italian · Chain · 3944 E 82nd St
• Amalfi
  Restaurant · Italian · 1351 W 86th St
• Augustino's Italian Restaurant
  Restaurant · Italian · 8028 S Emerson Ave Ste BB
• Bellacino's
  Restaurant · Italian · 7134 Woodland Dr
• Catello's Italian Art Cuisine
  Restaurant · Italian · 4901 E 82nd St
• Matteo’s Ristorante Italiano
  Restaurant · Italian · 1351 W 86th St
• Nicole-Taylor's Pasta and Market
  Restaurant · Italian · 1134 E 54th St
• Noble Roman's
  Restaurant · Italian · 1425 N Shadeland Ave
• Osteria Pronto
  Restaurant · Italian · 10 S West St
• Romano's Macaroni Grill
  Restaurant · Italian · Chain · 5720 W 86th St
• Sangiovese Ristorante
  Restaurant · Italian · 4110 E 82nd St
• Sauce On The Side
  Restaurant · Italian · 130 S Pennsylvania St Ste 2
• Keystone
  Restaurant · Italian · Chain · 8601 River Crossing Blvd, Indianapolis, IN 46240
• Marco's Restaurant
  Restaurant · Italian · 54th Street
• The Twisted Sicilian
  Restaurant · Italian · 2442 Central Ave
• Fashion Mall
  Restaurant · Italian · Chain · 3550 E. 86th St.

Italian elsewhere in Indiana

Among the Indiana cities in this guide, the most italian listings are in Fort Wayne (20), Carmel (15), Bloomington (12), South Bend (9), Evansville (7) and Fishers (7).

Run a italian spot in Indianapolis?

You share this list with 43 other italian listings. The ones guests reorder from are the ones that are easy to order from directly. Servestack gives you your own ordering site with zero commission, and Studio designs the menu, flyers and posts to go with it. Run your numbers with the commission savings calculator.

Place data from the Overture Maps Foundation (overturemaps.org), which includes data from Meta, Microsoft and Foursquare, used under the CDLA Permissive 2.0 and Apache 2.0 licenses. Restaurants open, close and move; check with the restaurant before you go. Data refreshed 2026-10-11.