Dessert and Ice Cream Shops in Fort Myers, FL

Desserts and ice cream in Fort Myers at a glance

• Desserts and ice cream is the 6th largest food category in Fort Myers, after coffee shops and cafes and bars.
• Its 5.4% share compares with 3.8% across the 506 cities in this guide, so Fort Myers leans toward desserts and ice cream.
• Of the 27 listed below, 20 are independent and 7 belong to chains; 25 list a website.

Dessert and Ice Cream Shops in Fort Myers

• Belgian Yummies
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · 2269 First St
• Best Ice Cream
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · 1401 Lee St
• Crumbl - Fort Myers
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · 7925 Dani Dr Ste 130
• Love Boat Homemade Ice Cream
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · Chain · 7977 Dani Dr #130
• Menchie's Frozen Yogurt
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · Chain · 4125 Cleveland Ave
• Scoops on First
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · 2250 First St
• Best Ice Cream
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · 2215 Winkler Ave
• Great American Cookies
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · 4125 Cleveland Ave
• I Want That Yummy
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · 1400 Colonial Blvd Ste 35
• La Michoacana Natural
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · Chain · 3629 Palm Beach Blvd
• Happy Scoop Ice Cream
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · 4125 Cleveland Ave #1135
• Sidecar Treats
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · 1512 Hendry St
• Churrico Factory
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · 4125 Cleveland Ave
• Maverick Grille
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · 4480 Fowler St Ste 110
• Dippin' Dots
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · Chain · 4125 Cleveland Ave
• Fuzziwig's Candy Factory
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · 4125 Cleveland Ave
• Gulf Coast Fudge Co
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · 1414 Bayview Ct
• Le Macaron French Pastries - Downtown Fort Myers
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · 1540 Broadway
• Morelia Gourmet Paletas
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · 4125 Cleveland Ave Ste 1627
• Orange Julius
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · Chain · 4125 Cleveland Ave Ste 1540
• Orange Leaf Frozen Yogurt
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · Chain · 3268 Forum Blvd Ste 205
• Roxi's Sweet Taste
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · 2366 E Mall Dr Apt 420
• Stefano Versace Gelateria Italiana & Gourmet
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · 4125 Cleveland Ave Ste 1140A
• Shelby's Sugar Shop
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · 4125 Clieveland Ave Ste 1627
• Rita’s of Fort Myers FL
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · Chain
• Wonderland at Pelican Preserve
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · 10580 Colonial Blvd #107
• La Michoacana Ice Cream & Desserts
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · 5781 Lee Blvd

Desserts and ice cream elsewhere in Florida

Among the Florida cities in this guide, the most desserts and ice cream listings are in Jacksonville (129), Orlando (126), Miami (121), Tampa (99), Miami Beach (63) and St. Petersburg (50).

Run a desserts and ice cream spot in Fort Myers?

You share this list with 26 other desserts and ice cream listings. The ones guests reorder from are the ones that are easy to order from directly. Servestack gives you your own ordering site with zero commission, and Studio designs the menu, flyers and posts to go with it. Run your numbers with the commission savings calculator.

Place data from the Overture Maps Foundation (overturemaps.org), which includes data from Meta, Microsoft and Foursquare, used under the CDLA Permissive 2.0 and Apache 2.0 licenses. Restaurants open, close and move; check with the restaurant before you go. Data refreshed 2026-10-11.