Pizza Places in Fort Collins, CO

Pizza in Fort Collins at a glance

• Pizza is the 3rd largest food category in Fort Collins, after coffee shops and cafes and bars.
• Its 7.3% share compares with 6.3% across the 506 cities in this guide, close to the national pattern.
• Of the 58 listed below, 29 are independent and 29 belong to chains; 58 list a website.

Pizza Places in Fort Collins

• Panhandler's Pizza
  Restaurant · Pizza · 2721 S College Ave
• Slyce Pizza Co.
  Restaurant · Pizza · 163 W Mountain Ave
• Blackjack Pizza
  Restaurant · Pizza · Chain · 4206 S College Ave #107
• Cosmo's Pizza
  Restaurant · Pizza · 1401 W Elizabeth St
• Domino's
  Restaurant · Pizza · Chain · 2110 W Elizabeth St
• Krazy Karl's Pizza And Sport Bar
  Restaurant · Pizza · 1124 W Elizabeth St
• Mama Roni's Pizza
  Restaurant · Pizza · Chain · 1006 Spring Creek Ln b4
• Otto Pint
  Restaurant · Pizza · 1100 Oakridge Dr
• Papa John's Pizza
  Restaurant · Pizza · Chain · 1275 E Magnolia St H
• Pizza Casbah
  Restaurant · Pizza · 126 W Laurel St
• Pizza Hut
  Restaurant · Pizza · Chain · 4643 S Mason St Larimer
• The Corner Slice
  Restaurant · Pizza · 172 N College Ave Unit C
• Beau Jo's
  Restaurant · Pizza · Chain · 205 N College Ave
• Old Chicago Pizza and Taproom
  Restaurant · Pizza · Chain · 4709 S Timberline Rd
• Domino's
  Restaurant · Pizza · Chain · 732 South Lemay Ste A
• Papa Johns
  Restaurant · Pizza · Chain · 731 e harmony rd
• Krazy Karl's Pizza and Sports Bar
  Restaurant · Pizza · 2620 S Timberline Rd
• Papa Murphy's
  Restaurant · Pizza · Chain · 238 East Harmony Road
• MOD Pizza
  Restaurant · Pizza · Chain · 1013 Centre Ave
• Little Caesars Pizza
  Restaurant · Pizza · Chain · 1115 W Prospect Rd
• Speak Cheesy Lounge
  Restaurant · Pizza · 122 N Mason St
• Domino's
  Restaurant · Pizza · Chain · 901 E Harmony Rd
• Mama Roni's Pizza
  Restaurant · Pizza · Chain · 4733 S Timberline Rd
• Cozzola's Pizza
  Restaurant · Pizza · 1112 Oakridge Dr #114
• Pizza Hut
  Restaurant · Pizza · Chain · 2936 Council Tree Avenue Larimer
• Domino's
  Restaurant · Pizza · Chain · 1880 North College Avenue
• Papa Murphy's | Take 'N' Bake Pizza
  Restaurant · Pizza · Chain · 737 South Lemay Avenue
• Little Caesars Pizza
  Restaurant · Pizza · Chain · 1514 E Harmony Rd
• Hungry Pizza
  Restaurant · Pizza · 1660 N College Ave
• Abo's Pizza
  Restaurant · Pizza · 200 W Prospect Rd
• Blackjack Pizza & Salads
  Restaurant · Pizza · 1501 W Elizabeth St
• Celestino's New York Pizza
  Restaurant · Pizza · 306 W Laurel St Ste 113
• CiCi's Pizza
  Restaurant · Pizza · Chain · 2721 S College Ave
• Donatos Pizza
  Restaurant · Pizza · Chain · 701 E Harmony Rd
• Grimaldi's Pizzeria
  Restaurant · Pizza · Chain · 327 E Foothills Pkwy Ste 110
• Justine's Pizza
  Restaurant · Pizza · 140 Boardwalk Dr
• MidiCi The Neapolitan Pizza Company
  Restaurant · Pizza · 3581 E Harmony Rd Ste 170
• Nick N Willys Pizza
  Restaurant · Pizza · 1015 S Taft Hill Rd
• Old Chicago
  Restaurant · Pizza · Chain · 147 S College Ave
• Pablo's Pizza
  Restaurant · Pizza · 2720 Council Tree Ave
• Panhandler's Pizza
  Restaurant · Pizza · 1220 W Elizabeth St
• Papa John's Pizza
  Restaurant · Pizza · Chain · 2170 W Drake Rd Unit B5
• Papa Murphy's Take 'N' Bake Pizza
  Restaurant · Pizza · Chain · 1031 S Taft Hill Rd
• Pizza Hut
  Restaurant · Pizza · Chain · 2567 S. Shields B-D
• Pizza Hut
  Restaurant · Pizza · Chain · 1612 N College Ave Ste K
• PizzaRev
  Restaurant · Pizza · 649 S College Ave
• Pudge Bros. Pizza
  Restaurant · Pizza · 814 S College Ave
• Pulcinella Pizzeria
  Restaurant · Pizza · 2550 E Harmony Rd Ste 101
• Uncle Vito's Too
  Restaurant · Pizza · 1015 S Taft Hill Rd
• Woody's Pizza
  Restaurant · Pizza · 518 W Laurel St
• Cozzola's Pizza - North
  Restaurant · Pizza · 241 Linden St
• Mama Roni's Pizza
  Restaurant · Pizza · 1006 Spring Creek Ln
• Marco's Pizza
  Restaurant · Pizza · Chain · 1630 S. Lemay Ave
• Toppers Pizza
  Restaurant · Pizza · Chain · 1501 W Elizabeth,
• Totally 80's Pizza
  Restaurant · Pizza · 2567 S Shields St
• Uncle's Pizzeria
  Restaurant · Pizza · 1717 S College Ave # 80525-1008
• Villa Pizza
  Restaurant · Pizza · Chain · Colorado State University
• Justine's Pizza
  Restaurant · Pizza · 1015 S Taft Hill Rd

Pizza elsewhere in Colorado

Among the Colorado cities in this guide, the most pizza listings are in Denver (235), Colorado Springs (142), Aurora (78), Boulder (51), Lakewood (48) and Thornton (34).

Run a pizza spot in Fort Collins?

You share this list with 57 other pizza listings. The ones guests reorder from are the ones that are easy to order from directly. Servestack gives you your own ordering site with zero commission, and Studio designs the menu, flyers and posts to go with it. Run your numbers with the commission savings calculator.

Place data from the Overture Maps Foundation (overturemaps.org), which includes data from Meta, Microsoft and Foursquare, used under the CDLA Permissive 2.0 and Apache 2.0 licenses. Restaurants open, close and move; check with the restaurant before you go. Data refreshed 2026-10-11.