Dessert and Ice Cream Shops in Fishers, IN

Desserts and ice cream in Fishers at a glance

• Desserts and ice cream is the 8th largest food category in Fishers, after pizza and bars.
• Its 3.9% share compares with 3.8% across the 506 cities in this guide, close to the national pattern.
• Of the 14 listed below, 6 are independent and 8 belong to chains; 14 list a website.

Dessert and Ice Cream Shops in Fishers

• Crumbl - Fishers
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · 8395 E 116th St
• Graeter's Ice Cream
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · Chain · 9367 Ambleside Dr
• Handel's Homemade Ice Cream
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · Chain · 8760 E 116th St
• Rita's
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · 8910 E 96th St
• Dairy Queen (Treat)
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · Chain · 10560 E 96th St
• Vintage Spoon Ice Cream Social
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · 11691 Fall Creek Rd Unit 115
• Kilwins Ice Cream - Chocolate - Fudge
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · Chain · 11594 Whistle Dr #130
• Bruster's Real Ice Cream
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · Chain · 12350 Olio Rd
• Gigi's Cupcakes
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · Chain · 8981 E 116th St
• Nerdy Girl Cupcakes
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · 12660 E 116th St
• Orange Leaf
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · 11675 Olio Rd
• Zogurts
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · 10134 Brooks School Rd
• Rita’s of Fishers IN
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · Chain
• Cold Stone Creamery
  Restaurant · Desserts and ice cream · Chain · 7462 East Fishers Station Dr

Desserts and ice cream elsewhere in Indiana

Among the Indiana cities in this guide, the most desserts and ice cream listings are in Indianapolis (110), Fort Wayne (47), Evansville (25), South Bend (20), Carmel (19) and Bloomington (15).

Run a desserts and ice cream spot in Fishers?

You share this list with 13 other desserts and ice cream listings. The ones guests reorder from are the ones that are easy to order from directly. Servestack gives you your own ordering site with zero commission, and Studio designs the menu, flyers and posts to go with it. Run your numbers with the commission savings calculator.

Place data from the Overture Maps Foundation (overturemaps.org), which includes data from Meta, Microsoft and Foursquare, used under the CDLA Permissive 2.0 and Apache 2.0 licenses. Restaurants open, close and move; check with the restaurant before you go. Data refreshed 2026-10-11.