Pizza Places in Elizabeth, NJ

Pizza in Elizabeth at a glance

• Pizza is the 3rd largest food category in Elizabeth, after latin american and bakeries and donuts.
• Its 6.5% share compares with 6.3% across the 506 cities in this guide, close to the national pattern.
• Of the 36 listed below, 27 are independent and 9 belong to chains; 35 list a website.

Pizza Places in Elizabeth

• Slices Pizza
  Restaurant · Pizza · 701 Elizabeth Ave
• Papa Johns Pizza
  Restaurant · Pizza · Chain · 312 Rahway Ave
• JP's Express Pizza
  Restaurant · Pizza · 190 Elmora Ave
• North End Pizza
  Restaurant · Pizza · 759 Jackson Ave
• Elizabeth Pizzeria
  Restaurant · Pizza · 871 Elizabeth Ave
• Bella Pizza
  Restaurant · Pizza · 5 Broad St
• Domino's
  Restaurant · Pizza · Chain · 1090 Elizabeth Ave
• Eli's Pizza Pasta
  Restaurant · Pizza · 766 Trumbull St
• Jersey Pizza USA
  Restaurant · Pizza · 829 Elizabeth Ave
• Little Caesars Pizza
  Restaurant · Pizza · Chain · 1114 Elizabeth Ave
• Mario's Famous Pizza
  Restaurant · Pizza · 94 Front St
• Pizza Hut
  Restaurant · Pizza · Chain · 655 Newark Ave Union
• Pizza Market & Arepas
  Restaurant · Pizza · 815 3rd Ave
• Tommy's Pizzeria & Restaurant
  Restaurant · Pizza · 1063 Fairmount Ave
• Domino's
  Restaurant · Pizza · Chain · 609 Westfield Ave.
• Mikey's Famous Pizzeria
  Restaurant · Pizza · 1000 S Elmora Ave
• John's Caffe Pizza & Caterers
  Restaurant · Pizza · 574 2nd Ave
• The Original Primo Pizza
  Restaurant · Pizza · 946 S Elmora Ave
• Sbarro
  Restaurant · Pizza · Chain · 651 Kapkowski Rd
• Queen's Pizza
  Restaurant · Pizza · Chain · 74 Broad St
• Crust Pizza
  Restaurant · Pizza · Chain · 429 N Broad St
• Pizza Express
  Restaurant · Pizza · 281 Westfield Ave
• Santillo's Brick Oven Pizza
  Restaurant · Pizza · 639 S Broad St
• Big C-zar's Pizzeria
  Restaurant · Pizza · 187 Elmora Ave
• Blimpie
  Restaurant · Pizza · Chain · 623 Spring St
• Daniel Pizza
  Restaurant · Pizza · 1033 N Broad St
• La Tostano
  Restaurant · Pizza · 603 Elizabeth Ave
• Lui's Pizzeria & Restaurant
  Restaurant · Pizza · 301 2nd St
• Luis Pizzeria
  Restaurant · Pizza · 301 2nd St
• Mario's Famous Pizza
  Restaurant · Pizza · 173 3rd St
• Pizza Appetito
  Restaurant · Pizza · 327 N Broad St
• Pizza Go Go
  Restaurant · Pizza · 204 Broad St
• Primo Pizza
  Restaurant · Pizza · 1127 Elizabeth Ave
• Pronto Pizza
  Restaurant · Pizza · 106 W Jersey St
• Breeney's Fried Chicken
  Restaurant · Pizza · 1033 N Broad St
• Victorinos Pizza and Restaurant
  Restaurant · Pizza · 1033 N Broad St

Pizza elsewhere in New Jersey

Among the New Jersey cities in this guide, the most pizza listings are in Jersey City (89), Newark (75), Paterson (33), Clifton (28) and Trenton (17).

Run a pizza spot in Elizabeth?

You share this list with 35 other pizza listings. The ones guests reorder from are the ones that are easy to order from directly. Servestack gives you your own ordering site with zero commission, and Studio designs the menu, flyers and posts to go with it. Run your numbers with the commission savings calculator.

Place data from the Overture Maps Foundation (overturemaps.org), which includes data from Meta, Microsoft and Foursquare, used under the CDLA Permissive 2.0 and Apache 2.0 licenses. Restaurants open, close and move; check with the restaurant before you go. Data refreshed 2026-10-11.