Pizza Places in Broken Arrow, OK

Pizza in Broken Arrow at a glance

• Pizza is the 3rd largest food category in Broken Arrow, after mexican and coffee shops and cafes.
• Its 9.4% share compares with 6.3% across the 506 cities in this guide, so Broken Arrow leans toward pizza.
• Of the 37 listed below, 13 are independent and 24 belong to chains; 34 list a website.

Pizza Places in Broken Arrow

• Casey's
  Restaurant · Pizza · Chain · 3825 E Kenosha St
• Rooski's Pizza
  Restaurant · Pizza · 800 S 9th St Ste D
• Little Caesars Pizza
  Restaurant · Pizza · Chain · 701 N Aspen Ave
• Andolini's Pizzeria
  Restaurant · Pizza · Chain · 222 S Main St
• Casey's
  Restaurant · Pizza · Chain · 2400 E Albany St
• Domino's
  Restaurant · Pizza · Chain · 620 W New Orleans St
• Hideaway Pizza
  Restaurant · Pizza · Chain · 1150 N 9th St
• Little Caesars Pizza
  Restaurant · Pizza · Chain · 737 W New Orleans St
• Marco's Pizza
  Restaurant · Pizza · Chain · 1061 N 9th St
• Papa Johns
  Restaurant · Pizza · Chain · 904 north elm place
• Papa Johns Pizza
  Restaurant · Pizza · Chain · 6323 S Elm Pl
• Pizza Hut
  Restaurant · Pizza · Chain · 802 S Aspen Ave Tulsa
• Marco's Pizza
  Restaurant · Pizza · Chain · 4650 W Houston St
• Pizza Hut
  Restaurant · Pizza · Chain · 3321 S. Elm Tulsa
• Uncle Vinny's NY Pizzeria
  Restaurant · Pizza · 322 W Kenosha St
• Cicis Pizza
  Restaurant · Pizza · Chain · 2435 W. Kenosha St.
• Mazzio’s Pizza & Wings
  Restaurant · Pizza · 1916 W New Orleans St
• Mr Gatti's Pizza
  Restaurant · Pizza · Chain · 6310 South Elm Place
• Papa Johns
  Restaurant · Pizza · Chain · 24192 e highway 51
• Tobies Pizzeria
  Restaurant · Pizza · 2424 W New Orleans St
• Zoie's Pizzeria
  Restaurant · Pizza · 2424 W New Orleans St
• JIMMYS NEW YORK PIZZERIA
  Restaurant · Pizza · 3312 S ELM Pl
• Pizza Hut
  Restaurant · Pizza · Chain · 10802 E. 71st South Tulsa
• Papa Murphy's | Take 'N' Bake Pizza
  Restaurant · Pizza · Chain · 610 W. Kenosha St
• Casey's
  Restaurant · Pizza · Chain · 4755 S Aspen Ave
• Franco's Pizza and Trattoria
  Restaurant · Pizza · 527 W WASHINGTON St S
• Domino's Pizza
  Restaurant · Pizza · Chain · 1921 S Elm Pl
• Mazzio's Pizza
  Restaurant · Pizza · 408 W Kenosha St
• Mazzios Pizza
  Restaurant · Pizza · 740 W New Orleans St
• Papa Murphy's
  Restaurant · Pizza · Chain · 2000 W Houston St
• Papa Murphy's Take 'N' Bake Pizza
  Restaurant · Pizza · Chain · 1209 E Kenosha St
• Simple Simon's Pizza
  Restaurant · Pizza · 2423 W Kenosha St
• B52 Pizza
  Restaurant · Pizza · 21910 E 71st St S
• CiCi's Pizza
  Restaurant · Pizza · Chain · 732 W New Orleans St Ste 124
• Pizza Hut Express
  Restaurant · Pizza · Chain · 1150 E Hillside Dr
• Old World Pizza
  Restaurant · Pizza · 732 W New Orleans St Ste 120
• Red's Pizzeria
  Restaurant · Pizza · 24192 E Highway 51

Pizza elsewhere in Oklahoma

Among the Oklahoma cities in this guide, the most pizza listings are in Oklahoma City (206), Tulsa (120), Norman (45), Edmond (38) and Lawton (35).

Run a pizza spot in Broken Arrow?

You share this list with 36 other pizza listings. The ones guests reorder from are the ones that are easy to order from directly. Servestack gives you your own ordering site with zero commission, and Studio designs the menu, flyers and posts to go with it. Run your numbers with the commission savings calculator.

Place data from the Overture Maps Foundation (overturemaps.org), which includes data from Meta, Microsoft and Foursquare, used under the CDLA Permissive 2.0 and Apache 2.0 licenses. Restaurants open, close and move; check with the restaurant before you go. Data refreshed 2026-10-11.